COURAGE
This evening’s Freestyle in Rotterdam was the reason why I love coming to this show, even with the cold and driving rain which tested the courage of both horses and riders. Though the sky opened up just as Edward Gal and Totilas were about to enter the arena, so much so in fact that it was hard to make him out in his grey jacket on the black stallion through the torrential down-pore, this pair was simply magnificient! In all my years I can honestly say I have never seen a more fantastic equine athlete in our sport of Dressage. There are other wonderful horses and it has been the case in the past that Totilas is beatable if (but I will say only if) he makes mistakes out of tension. That being said, he had every right to show tension tonight but looked as if the whole thing were a walk in the park, thus his 90.143%! Courage!
Adelinda Cornelissen and Parzival both showed amazing courage as well when just as she was going down the outside of the arena toward A, the bill boards on the entire short side of the main arena began to change repeatedly to show the various sponsors of the show. Parzival had every reason to turn and run and would have but for the patience of Adelinda who took it in stride and, after finally getting him down to the entrance, had just enough time to relax him enough to produce a very nice, if not mistake-free ride for 2nd place and 83.929%. Courage!
I honestly would have had Imke Schellekens-Bartels and Sunrise 2nd but she received 81.250 and was 3rd. Her music was, for me, the best of he night. Produced by Jost Peters with one of the finest pianists in the world, I was absolutely carried away by the gorgeous piece, both the story and thre drama. And Sunrise had a lovely and harmonious test. Courage!
But, friends, that is where the show went from one in which I may have exchanged the spots of Imke and Adelinda but was still happy for them both as well as for Edward - 3 great rides which were easy to give very high marks - to feeling discouraged that there is still a total lack of courage displayed by too many judges. It really doesn’t take a lot of courage to score something fantastic with high marks or something absolutely insufficient with very low ones. But it does require courage to give certain famous riders and horses low marks for movements which are not only insufficient but actually not even meeting the definition of the movement in the FEI Handbook. Horses which did no discernible piaffe whatsoever and had irregular trots and passage as well as huge laboured pirouettes were allowed to have scores above both Belinda Trussell and Ashley Holzer, both of whom had lovely, mistake-free rides with their horses tonight. You can say that I am biased but I guarantee that if you watch the video of all of the rides this evening, you will agree with me. I even believe that were I able to sit with the video from all of the rides with the judges and go through them being played next to each other, they would come out with a different outcome. This is why I am hopeful that the Supervisory Panel which now only can correct errors of counting (as in tempi changes) will be able to flag inappropriate judging and change scores which just don’t belong being given, whether too high or low. Only then can we hope that judges will step up to the plate and display the courage of their convictions, and if they are simply not good enough at their job, the Supervisory Panel should direct the FEI Dressage Committee to have them demoted, plain and simple.
The riders,trainers, supporters, owners, and sponsors deserve to have fair and courageous judging. And until there is, I will go on complaining about it regardless of whether people want to hear me say it or not. I guess when you’ve been around in the sport as long as I have, if nothing else, I have Courage.
Cheers!
RD






















